Ice baths are often promoted for recovery and resilience, but the body’s reaction to extreme cold is far from simple.
Julian E. Stelzer, professor of physiology and biophysics at Case Western Reserve University, explains that sudden immersion in icy water triggers the cold shock response. This begins with a rapid rise in heart rate, breathing, and blood pressure as the nervous system responds to stress. Hyperventilation can continue for minutes while the body fights to stabilize itself.
Peripheral blood vessels constrict, forcing blood away from the skin and limbs and toward vital organs such as the heart and brain. This mechanism preserves core temperature but also places extra strain on the cardiovascular system. To generate heat, skeletal muscles contract involuntarily, causing shivering that boosts energy use and helps the body resist further cooling.
These reactions highlight both the potential benefits and risks of ice baths. Short exposures may support circulation, reduce inflammation, and build mental toughness. However, the sudden cardiovascular stress can be dangerous for those with heart conditions or high blood pressure. Understanding how the body adapts to cold stress helps explain why ice baths remain a powerful, yet challenging, wellness practice.
More: Comprehensive guide to cervix biopsy aftercare
Mental benefits of ice baths
Early research suggests that ice baths may support mental well-being, though studies remain limited. Cold water exposure appears to stimulate the release of endorphins and noradrenaline, which can improve mood, reduce fatigue, and increase alertness.
In one small study of 33 adults, a five-minute cold water dip enhanced attentiveness and lowered anxiety and distress. Another study found that young adults who immersed a hand in cold water for three minutes felt less sleepy after being woken in the night and performed math problems faster than those using warm water.
While these results are promising, both studies were small and involved scenarios that don’t reflect everyday life. To confirm mental health benefits in more practical settings, larger and more rigorous trials are needed. For now, ice baths may offer a short-term boost in energy and focus, but their broader effects remain under investigation.
More: Self-Care: Why spa visits are essential for well-being?
Potential benefits and risks of cold water immersion
Cold water immersion has become a popular practice, but most of the claimed health benefits are based on anecdotal evidence rather than large-scale clinical studies. Research on athletes shows mixed results, with outcomes often depending on the type of exercise.
Still, potential benefits include:
- Blood sugar regulation and weight loss: Shivering activates muscles in a way similar to exercise, which can improve glucose uptake and insulin sensitivity. Metabolic rate also rises temporarily, helping burn more calories.
- Immune system support: Cold exposure may boost white blood cell count, though the mechanism is unclear. However, prolonged exposure can impair immunity and increase the risk of hypothermia.
- Reduced inflammation: Cold reduces acute inflammation after injuries. Whether it helps with chronic inflammation in conditions like arthritis or autoimmune disease remains uncertain.
- Improved mood: Some studies suggest cold plunges can reduce anxiety and depression, at least temporarily. Effects may come from hormonal release (adrenaline, noradrenaline, dopamine) and the social aspect of group plunges.
- Workout recovery: Cold therapy is often used by athletes to reduce soreness and speed recovery.
Despite these potential benefits, there are significant risks. The sudden cold shock response can be dangerous for people with heart problems, high blood pressure, poor circulation, or a history of stroke. Medications like beta blockers may further limit the body’s ability to adapt to the stress of a sudden cold, raising the risk of arrhythmia or heart attack. In some cases, panic from the shock can impair judgment and increase the risk of drowning.
Cold water immersion can be invigorating and beneficial for some, but it should always be approached with caution, especially for individuals with underlying health conditions.
More: Which plants promote relaxation?
What is cryotherapy, and do ice baths really help?
Cryotherapy, or cold therapy, comes from the Greek word krýos, meaning icy cold. It describes different ways of cooling the body, including:
- Ice application – using an ice pack on a specific area.
- Cold showers – standing under cold running water.
- Cold water immersion (CWI) – plunging into water at 60°F (15°C) or colder.
- Whole-body cryotherapy (WBC) – stepping into a chamber that blasts freezing air.
Supporters of ice baths and cold plunges often claim benefits like faster recovery, better circulation, reduced inflammation, and improved mood. However, scientific evidence remains limited. For example, a study published in Nature Scientific Reports tested the Wim Hof method, which combines cold water immersion, breathing exercises, and meditation, over 15 days. Researchers found no significant changes in blood pressure, heart rate, heart function, or mood.
Other studies suggest cryotherapy may offer some benefits, but results are modest, and the research is not strong enough to fully confirm the claims. The reality is that many effects are short-term or depend on how consistently and safely the practice is used.
Still, if cryotherapy is practiced with caution, it can be a safe ritual that provides a sense of resilience and personal challenge. Even if the physical benefits are modest, the mental boost and feeling of toughness may be worthwhile for those who enjoy the icy plunge.
More: 6 signs of adulthood autism
Cold water immersion vs. other cold therapies
According to Julian E. Stelzer, the key difference between cold water immersion, cold showers, and whole-body cryotherapy lies in how much body temperature drops. Cold showers usually range from 50–60°F (about 10–15°C) and affect mostly the skin and peripheral circulation. Polar plunges expose the whole body to icy water just above freezing, around 35–40°F (1–4°C), causing a stronger core response. Whole-body cryotherapy is even colder, sometimes dropping to -200°F (-129°C), but exposure lasts only a few minutes and uses freezing air instead of water.
Ice baths and polar plunges are widely used by athletes to speed recovery. The theory is that cold reduces body temperature, blood flow, and inflammation in muscles. However, Stelzer notes that evidence does not strongly support this. Reducing blood flow might even slow protein synthesis, which is important for muscle repair. Some inflammation is also necessary for recovery, so eliminating it may not be helpful. Overall, for long-term muscle health, polar plunges offer little proven benefit.
As for immune function, a few studies suggest cold plunges could increase white blood cell counts. Yet most of this research involved regular cold water swimmers, where exercise itself may have played a role. For casual or occasional plungers, there is little evidence of meaningful immune benefits.
In short, cold water immersion triggers a stronger body response than showers, but science shows only limited recovery and immune effects — most benefits remain anecdotal.
More: How to focus your brain?
Ice baths as a complement, not a foundation
Cold plunges and cryotherapy can be viewed as an optional addition to a healthy lifestyle, not a replacement for its core foundations. Regular exercise, balanced nutrition, quality sleep, and effective stress management should remain the main priorities. Ice baths may serve as a supportive practice for recovery or mental resilience, but they are best treated as a complement rather than the centerpiece of wellness.
For those who choose to try them, it is safest to begin at home, in a shower or bathtub, with brief exposures of 30–60 seconds in cool (not freezing) water. Over time, immersion can be gradually extended to 5–10 minutes, always with caution and awareness of individual limits. This approach ensures that cold therapy remains a beneficial garnish to overall health, rather than a risky or misplaced focus.
Sources: Case Western Reserve University, Mayo Clinic
